History of Conch Key
By Jerry S. Wilkinson
   The author has very little documented information of Conch Key . The first mention he finds of the use of the name Conch Key is by F. W. Gerdes in his Reconnaissance of the Florida Reefs and All the Keys in 1849. His quote is "The first islands between Duck Key and Viper Id. [Long Key] are named Conch Keys." No doubt this included Walker Key, or Little Conch Key which is the smaller Key farther west.
<>      Conch Key ocean side is an superb example of dredge and fill. It simply did not exist until it was filled - it was an excellent shallow water lobstering area. I know this as it was not there when I moved to Key West in 1947.  So it joins  the man-made parcels such as Trumbo Point, Key Colony Beach, the two bayside islands of Craig Key. Perhaps I should include the newly named Veterans Key south of Lower Matecumbe Keys - it is the remains of a bridge approach built by the World War One veterans.
      The section of a map to the right has no surveyor name and is of the Duck Key area which included Conch Keys. As one can see it is Section 15 and is of Township 65 South and Range 34 East. The larger Key is Conch Key, the subject of this page. The government survey of the Duck Key area by Charles F. Smith in 1874 does not include the Conch Keys. If you are unfamiliar with this area, for a 1966 nautical map (it is a large file), please  Click HERE, then the Back Arrow. 
-
-
-
-
-
       Conch Key was used by the Florida East Coast Railway as a construction camp site; however, not much of this use is found. In 1944, Frank M. Coward, an adventurous traveler, purchased the island of about 5 acres from the state of Florida for $11,000. According to the Key West Citizen dated July 19, 1944, ". . . County Tax Assessor, Claude A. Gandolfo, said this morning that the key, that is the real estate part of it, has never been on the assessor's books because it had always been owned by Florida since it attained statehood [1845], but, he explained that, since his assuming office, he had levied personal taxes against the pumphouse, log cabin and two cottages that were on the key, but had been unable to learn to whom the key had been leased by the state.
      "The log cabin burned down two years ago, but the two cottages and the pumphouse are still there. The latter is used to supply water and electricity.
      "Another Key was sold yesterday. Trustees of the dissolved Anchor Lodge Corporation conveyed Ohio Key comprising 51.16 acres to ... for $15,000.
      "Both Conch and Ohio keys are on the new Overseas Highway."
      Some interesting Keys history are contained in this article. The so-called log cabin was not the typical log cabin but what was generally referred to as a "tie cabin." The tie meaning cross ties from railroad construction. The cross ties were interlaced together to build as large of a structure as needed. A few continue to exist in the Lower Keys. Supposedly, the railroad had used the tie cabin for a multitude of purposes. Later the State Road Department when building the second Overseas Highway in 1938 used the structure on Conch Key. The electricity referred to had just been installed as part of the Florida Keys Electric Cooperative. 
-
   Coward built himself a house which he used as a home and a place to build his dream-boat, a 44-foot ketch, Don Pancho. It was a combination boat yard, marina and living quarters.  When the boat was completed, part of the house had to be removed for the launching. Coward died in 1966 and E.V. Jones purchased the house. E. V. Jones and his wife, Ruth, owned the Conch Key boat yard in 1954 and died in 1978. Jones was the organizer of the Conch Key Volunteer Fire Department and Rescue Corps. Jones also had organized a disaster unit under the Key West Red Cross chapter which served the island well after Hurricane Donna in 1960.
       There were few residents on the island until about 1952 which was around the time many of the Upper Keys had a burst of growth. One contributing factor was the opening of Coral Shores High School, the first Monroe County high school outside of Key West. It is said that some of the first residents were the Liebys, Jones, Hunts, Doolittles and Pearl Jacobs, a niece of Coward, yet I do not see early phone numbers listed for these names.  We must remember that in earlier times phones were not a necessity and considered an expensive luxury. Also, some did not have telephone lines available, but one could always pay for their own poles.
      From my 1954 Southern Bell and Telegraph phone book, I see the following names and numbers:
- Hunt Marine Supply   2042
- Mac & Ann's Fishing Haven  2186
- McCarthy, M. J. Capt.   2185
- Mitchell, George   2047
- Tiny's Cottages   2186
- Tiny's Place   2041
    The Hunts, Doolittles, Phillips and the Fire Department are in the 1964 phone book.
        The years passed comfortably in the fishing and retirement community of Conch Key and many passed by without notice. In 1997 part of Conch Key made the news media. A few years earlier the Billy Wagner family had sold the property of Coral Key Village Mobile Home Park. This was composed of about 50 mobile homes and about 100 residents. The new owners wished to develop and modernize the property with a marina, an restaurant and about 30 townhouses and detached houses.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
       In October of 1997 the mobile home residents received an eviction notice effective December 1998 so the new project could go forward. Faced with no place to go, the Home Owners Association as a cooperative offered to purchase the park. Both sides faced legal problems, one was that the property zoning  was not zoned for either use. A law suit ensued and the cooperative purchased the property in August 2001. 
-
-
-
-
      We began this page with Conch Keys, plural. The second Key, or the Key to the southwest and totally on the ocean,  is known as Walker's Key by many and is discussed on another web page. 
      This page is ended with another photo of the proud Conch Key Volunteer Fire Department. 
-
-
-
-
-
Use the Back Arrow to return to reading previous page, or
Go to the History of Walker's Key,  Click HERE, or 
To return to the Specific Locations and Keys homepage, Click HERE.
Return to Historeum
/b>